John Allison, a retired sheriff with 28 years of exemplary service under his belt, quickly formed a plan in his mind. This was a huge opportunity for him to taste a nice piece of pussy. From what he had heard off-screen, there was at least a second girl in the lot.
He couldn’t wait for Jude to call him back. What was taking her so long, dammit?
The phone rang. It was an antiquated black dial model with a straight cable that had once belonged to his father. He picked it up, holding his breath.
It was Jude all right.
“Oh, it is that old house?! Are you sure, Jude?” he said, doing his best to speak calmly and hide his high excitement. This was exactly what he was hoping for; he had strongly suspected this to be the old MacTavish house, and now it was confirmed.
Jude was positive. The signal came from there.
Making sure to keep calm, he called the sheriff’s office. A young, rookie deputy picked up the phone.
“Hi Mr. Allison! What can I do for you? Has a ghost been sighted somewhere? Ha! Ha! Ha! Ha!”
“Well, perhaps there is, Bud. There seems to be a bunch of youths doing some practical joke or throwing a party at the old MacTavish house. I’m just going to take a look over there and make sure everything is all right… No, don’t bother. It’s probably all fine; I just want them to see a uniform so they don’t break anything. I kind of love this old haunted house… Yep! Yep. I’ll sure drop by for a beer next Friday night… All right, bye young fella!”
“Excellent! The coast is clear!” thought the ex-sheriff as he hung up the phone.
He went to his son’s room and told him to get changed to go out. His son was 27 and a virgin. His life had always been nothing but mysery anytime he had been at school, at work or anywhere else where there were normal people. Let’s just say that Isaac was on the really ugly side of things on the attraction spectrum. Isaac had tons of sexual urges that had never found any venting medium other than his hand and on-screen images of naked girls.
His father had to repeat twice when he said they were going to the MacTavish house to fuck some pretty chicks. Isaac couldn’t believe his ears.
“Yes, sonny!” boasted John Allison. “Don’t you think it’s time for you to lose your cherry? And I’ve seen the girls. They are really pretty!”
Isaac was quickly dressed and out. He took his seat on the ride side in his dad’s 4×4 pick-up. Both men were wearing plaid shirts and jeans along with country boots and stetson hats. The ex-county sheriff was wearing his gun belt with a loaded magnum .44, which he wasn’t expecting to use in the least, except perhaps to have one of the girls sucking the barell… after he had taken the bullets out of course. His friend Brian had always reminded him of this, and he was right.
As he drove, the tall old man thought of his failed marriage. All had been good while he was in office, but once he was retired, things got bad and went from bad to worse. Amanda had suspected he was seeing some young female deputy behind her back. She had been right.
Fucking that 28-year-old law enforcement girl had been a fulfilled fantasy; what a rush when he had mounted her as she took him bent over on the hood of her patrol car! The affair had cost him his 33-year marriage. Was it worth it? Maybe, maybe not.
Becca, that was that girl’s name, had refused to let Isaac touch her, but John had kept insisting. She was adamant; the idea of doing anything intimate with this ugly young man was enough to make her vomit. He loved his son so much that he kept pressuring her, as he knew it would be such a huge turn-on to watch the red-haired beauty getting drilled by his not-so-handsome son.
In spite of her patience, Becca had exploded in anger one night when John asked her to “only” let Isaac suck her breasts. That was it! John’s demands had followed a downward ease-up, from letting Isaac fuck her missionary style, to taking him doggy style so she wouldn’t have to see his face, to giving him a blowjob, and now down to letting him play with her boobs. She had had enough and slammed the door as she left for good.
It had been three years since John had had a woman in his life. He had thought of apologizing to Becca and getting back with her on her own condition (no Isaac), but he was too proud. He had also thought of abducting Becca so he and Isaac could rape her over and over again, but he feared the consequences if she spoke up and nothing was triggering him to take such a bold step as to become a criminal.
Now, there had been a trigger — ElyzaPlaysOuija and her surprising video!
He was sure Elyza was there. She must have been the girl he had heard whimpering and groaning off-screen. As he drove on the forest trail and was getting near the old house, John took his cellphone and called Brian, his longtime friend. He wanted them to know he was coming so he wouldn’t risk getting accidentally shot by Rick and Dean.
Dean had been the guy on screen, and John knew that Dean never did anything without his twin brother Rick, who was the “Gunnie Boy” and a former Marine Sergeant.
“Hello John! Long time no see!” Brian said to the retired sheriff as he hugged him and shook hands with the man’s son.
While his friend shook hands with the Martin brothers and Ron, Brian looked at Elyza’s pretty face, then at Isaac stay-home face. He felt a gigantic erection starting to push the front of his denim trousers as he pictured the scary-ugly guy raping the pretty blonde.
This was going to be fun! The more people, the merrier!
The girls and both male prisoners had been escorted outside, one by one, to relieve themselves. Julie had been scared by the sound of an owl on a tree as she took a piss while shivering from the chilly night. Then, she remembered that she was naked and the captive of a bunch of creeps and she got a lot scarier. Were they going to kill her along with her friends after they were done? There were no witnesses.
The old men had brought some nice food — sandwiches and macaroni salad along with canned beer. They even gave chocolate to the girls, who felt a tinge of gratitude as the chocolate tasted like heaven after what they had just been through.
Then two newcomers came.
“Look at that creepo guy!” thought Julie as she saw Isaac. Elyza and her sister Cynthia looked at him with as much terror as if he were a genuine zombie. He still looked better than a living dead, but barely. Isaac was a freak of nature and not in a good way.
“Ladies!” Brian bellowed. “We have guests. And here (putting his hand on Isaac’s well-built shoulder) we have a very special guest!”
Brian looked at the three girls in silence, basking in the terrified looks they were casting at the “special guest”. Then he gave them a command… “Say hi to your new friend Isaac!”
None of the girls made a sound. Brian looked at them angrily and gestured in a threatening way.
Elyza got the message…
“Uh… Hi… I… Izak…”
Brian shouted in anger…
“You disappoint me! Either you say hi and do everything I say or we will let Isaac rape one of you in the ass and then all of you will have to suck his dick and taste shit! So, now, say hi to Isaac!”
“Hi, Isaac,” Elyza uttered with reluctance. Brian looked at Julie, then at Cynthia and nodded.
“Hell… Hello Isaac!” Julie blurted out.
“Hi Isaac, n… nice meeting you…” Cynthia let slip.
“That’s better, but you still have way to go,” Brian conceded, still looking at them with a stern face. “Now, ask him which one of you he’d like to fuck first! Come on! We don’t have all night…”
All three girls began to bawl and wail in horror. They knew it! They knew this dreaded request was coming next!
“Come on! Say it!” Brian said in a dead-cold voice while giving them a spine-chilling stare. Then he smiled and said “The guy’s a virgin. He wants his trick or treat for Halloween and you are going to give him both! A trick with your mouth to make him hard and a treat with the treasures of your body!”
Isaac was staring at the girls. He was especially staring at pretty Elyza, who began to cry in despair as she sensed his preferrence for her blonde’s charms.
Indeed, the blonde girl reminded Isaac of one of the most popular girls in his high school. He had given her a short note on a paper, to declare his love for her, and she had read it aloud in front of the entire classroom so everyone could make fun of him. He never forgot. Now, the 27-year-old boy was going to punish that girl, whose nude charms he was drinking with his virgin eyes. Isaac felt the beginning of a raging erection; what was it going to feel like, to be inside her and explode? Tonight was the night!
As the girls were terror-frozen again, Brian took a bowie knife and poised it near the floor where it was just above Ted’s little finger.
“Ladies, either you cooperate or you hear your handsome friend screaming as he loses his fingers one by one. Your decision! After his fingers, I’ll start cutting off your nipples! Your choice!”
Elyza spoke first…
“Hello, Isaac. Uh… Which one… Which one of us would you like to fuck?”
“You, blonde girl, you! I want to fuck you so deep you will never forget!” Isaac replied, panting hard as the reality was truly dawning on him. He was about to fuck a girl, and a gorgeous one at that!
Elyza looked at the floor and bitterly sobbed in terror as if she were about to be carried to the gallows to be hung.
“Yeh, that’s my girl!” Brian approved.
“Oh, God! Now this will be something to see!” said Rick.
“Perfect for Halloween night!” added Dean.
“Come on, son! You got this! Show them who’s boss!” added John.
Brian quickly uncuffed Elyza’s hands and untied her ankles. He then escorted the nude blonde right near Isaac. Elyza was frozen as a statue and unable to look at his freakish face.
Then, she yelped in terrified disgust as the 27-year-old virgin grabbed her petite shoulders and forced-kissed her! The loud slurping sounds filled the room as he proceeded to wet her entire face with his gross attempt at a kiss.
Julie started to bawl and protest as Brian also untied her.
“Since the guy is a virgin, I’d say he deserves two girls at the same time!” Brian announced with a wicked smile.
“Nice touch for my boy, Brian!” the retired sheriff said.
“Indeed!” Rick added.
Julie totally freaked out and felt envy for her own sister. It looked like Cynthia wasn’t going to have to fuck that THING. Getting raped by the old creeps now seemed a bit like a date with a handsome actor in comparison.
“Fuck! Fuck! Fuck!” Julie thought as Brian kindly escorted her where poor Elyza was enduring Isaac’s leecherous assaults. “I thought it couldn’t get worse! Yuck. What a nightmare!” she added in her mind.
Isaac contemplated Julie’s lovely feet as she sat with her legs crossed nearby to remain on stand-by under Brian’s watchful eyes.
Then, Brian ordered Elyza to get down on her knees and suck the ugly man’s cock. The five old creeps all watched Elyza’s moving curves, especially her pale butt, as she delightfull got down on her knees, where she sobbed and unzipped Isaac’s jeans with a shaky hand.
John Alison had a raging erection as she watched the pretty teen girl taking his son’s hard prick inside her mouth. She began pleasuring him with rivers of tears streaming down her pretty face, her cheek showing the bulge of his meat as she bobbed back and forth under the freak’s sickly grunting. Elyza thought she was going to die as the foul flavor filled her entire soul. She feared Brian, so she kept sucking the guy’s dick.
When she had tasted his precum, she was ordered to stop and wait for Isaac’s command.
The sheriff’s son was to choose which position she was going to take him in. He decided to strip himself naked and lie down on his back. Elyza felt herself almost fainting as Brian ordered her to straddle him.
When Elyza was on top of him and he guided his eager dick inside her entrance, Isaac still couldn’t believe this was happening. He filled the room with his bear-like grunting, and Elyza yelped in aroused disgust, as she got impaled in his dick and he began bouncing her on his lap, grabbing her lithe waist and looking at her perky breasts bouncing away in rhythm with her whimpers. Isaac loved the way the lamplight played on her pale nipples.
They were once again live for a bunch geeks somewhere in Nevada. The teenage boys had managed to hack Elyza’s shut-down channel and resume the live camera shooting. The dorky high-tech nerds baked some popcorn and watched Elyza getting drilled on top of that impossibly ugly dude in the middle of that spooky-looking room. They were recording everything and would then sell the footage; this was really hot stuff!
Brian ordered Julie to come near Elyza and make herself wet by playing with herself. He then asked Isaac if he wanted to try the brunette for a while.
Unsurprisingly, Isaac said “Yes” amid his lewd grunts. There was something in Julie’s face that made most guys want to fuck her or at least wish for her mouth pleasuring their cock.
Julie cried and protested, but she remembered the bowie knife and obeyed. Before long, she had taken Elyza’s spot and was bouncing on the ugly man’s lap. Brian ordered her to look straight into his face as he delightfully watched Julie’s small breasts being cupped by Isaac in a gross display of beauty vs. the beast.
After a few strokes with the pretty brunette, Isaac asked for Elyza’s return, but he surprised Brian as he requested that Julie straddle his face so he could eat her pussy while fucking her blond friend. Isaac had noticed Julie’s lush triangle of black cunt hair and he wanted to taste her turf.
Moments later, Elyza was bouncing herself on Isaac’s dick while having a perfect view on Julie’s butt. Elyza felt a surprising jolt of arousal as she watched her friend’s firm buttocks getting grabbed and squeezed by the freakish man who was now tasting a pussy for the first time in his hapless life. This arousal was forcing loud whimpers out of her as she surged quickly toward an inevitable climax.
Isaac felt the blonde’s climaxing spasms on his dick and heard her orgasmic scream while he ate the brunette’s pussy. Oh, God! This was so amazing! He felt the brunette’s growing arousal as well as her juices bathing his mouth; he also felt that she liked even better his caressing hands on her butt. He took his decision and ordered the blonde off her, which she did immediately with unfathomable relief.
The brunette was now straddling Isaac with her vagina stretched and filled with his throbbing dick. He ordered her to stoop down and kiss him and began raping her as rough as he could while cupping and kneading her butt. He heard her growing moaning and felt her breath on his face as he licked her cheek while feeling her tight vagina gripping him on its velvety glove.
Julie couldn’t believe it! This freak’s hands on her butt were driving her body nuts! Do what she will, her body just loved this man’s touch on her smooth buns. She dreaded her upcoming climax; her only hope was the man filling her up before she unwillingly hit her jackpot. She was sweating profusely and giving him a magic scent to remember her by.
Unfortunately for Julie, Isaac had some degree of porn-induced erectile weakness. It is only the intense hotness of the setting that had allowed him to get hard, but his ejaculation was very long in coming. He kept bouncing her on his lap while kneading her butt and grunting like an ape against her face.
“Oh noo! Oh noo! I’m coming…” Julie cried, then she let out a loud series of high-pitched moans amid her cries of shame, while her monster-ugly rapist kept relentlessly raping her and cupping her ass, using the manly touch that had defeated her.
Shortly after, Isaac filled the room with his scream of relief as he blissfully erupted in a biblical-scale load inside the lovely brunette, consummating their improbable intimity. He had to stop bouncing her on him as the movement got painful. As he stopped, he uttered one last growl and his dick spewed another glorious rope of thick jizz.
Julie took all this wet heat while sobbing and crying. She had no time to recover.
John, the father and retired sheriff, had been watching and masturbating. As soon as his son had pulled out of the brunette, he laid her down on the floor and urgently raped her in missionary style. It only lasted thirty seconds of extreme pounding where the poor girl was utterly shaked as if she were electrocuted, then the old man roared like a madman as he blissfully filled her up.
“Oh… Shit!” he bellowed as he dumped the last of his load inside the teenage student. What a fucking rush! He hadn’t got his cum inside such a young girl in forty years.
A few paces away, Brian was mounting Elyza doggy style. He kept calling her “my good girl” as he raped her with unbridled abandon, until he bolted and let out a long-winded growled as he looked down on her beauty and delightfully felt his hot bolts of seed shooting out of him to search for her youthful egg.
God dammit. This was good! With all this, he had even forgotten to get a taste of her sexy feet.
In Nevada, the bunch of geeks were enjoying the show and masturbating hard. Elyza was becoming viral as these guys were relaying the footage on a network with their dorky online friends, who in turn relayed it to their own friends, etc. She and Julie were going to become celebrities on PornHub and in every university campus worldwide.
TO BE CONTINUED
